This was a fun, quirky book that didn't take itself too seriously. Light, fluffy was what I was in the mood for and I got that with this. I liked Jill and her sarcasm. The mystery could have been fleshed out more. Whole chapters go by and with no mention of the mystery. Then, Jill has a moment towards the end and BOOM! Solved. Just. Like. That. That's why this isn't a straight up 4 for me. Great main character- check. Fun secondary characters- check and check. I think me favorite was Winky.
I am using this for the witches square.