Taken all together a 2* is the most I can rate this book. The 1st 4 in this were meh (and Shalvis's was disappointing- Ella was TSTL). I'm not going to waste my time. But the last story- Fish Out of Water (Cat Johnson) was the best. This story was a strong 3.5* for me. I enjoyed the swap- a cowgirl meets nerdy professor. Carla was likable and I thought her insecurities were understandable. I also liked Mark and thought he was a good fit. My only issue was it was too short!