I'm giving this one a 4.5 (and I rounded up). The plot thickens! I loved Scarlet and Wolf. I did like the twist on the pack. Cinder is slowly coming into her own and with the addition of new (dare I hope?) friends she will be able to destroy Levana. I would like to see her accept who she is as well. My only issue: ONE book a year. I highly recommend this series, but it would be perfectly okay to wait until the 3rd book is out in 2014 before starting (so far I think 4 are planned).